回复 全回 转寄 删除 上一封 下一封 返回 发件人： "Bill Chen" 存入地址簿 阻止发信人 加入过滤器 收件人： HELENE.BARCELO@asu.edu 抄送： jliu@emich.edu, wxw@cfc.nankai.edu.cn 邮件主题： Re: Reference Number: 1358 ---- Author: William Y. C. Chen 发件日期： Wed, 19 Dec 2007 13:56:03 +0800 看信件原文 打印信件 来信内容: 选择内码:from:GBKGB2312BIG-5UTF-8 to:GBKBIG-5UTF-8 Dear Helene, There is no problem at all. Actually, we realized that the stronger result by other authors as well as the proof fall into the same framework as ours. Of course, we have to admit that technically speaking it is stronger than ours. Of course, we are not discouraged to continue to submit to JCTA. Best regards. Bill >From: Helene Barcelo >Reply-To: >To: Journal >Subject: Re: Reference Number: 1358 ---- Author: William Y. C. Chen >Date:Tue, 18 Dec 2007 18:54:50 -0700 (MST) > >Dear Bill , > >We received the referee report on your paper, > >"Families of Sets with Intersecting Clusters," > >jointly authored with J. Liu and L.X.W. Wang. > >As you will see in the report this is a delicate situation. >The refere find your paper interesting and very nicely written. >Unfortunately, almost at the same time of your submission we also >we received another paper with stronger results. > >After careful considerations and discussions, >the editorial board of JCT (A) felt that while your paper most >certainly deserves publication, we cannot accept it for publication in the Journal. > >I regret any disappointment and inconvenience that this causes you, >and thank you for your interest in the Journal of Combinatorial Theory, >Series A. I also hope that this decision will not deter you from >submitting to the Journal in the future. > > >Yours sincerely, > >Helene Barcelo >Editor-in-Chief >Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A. > > > > >==================================================================== > Helene Barcelo barcelo@asu.edu > Professor PSA 736 > Department of Mathematics & Statistics Tel: (480) 965-3551 > Arizona State University Fax: (480) 965-8119 > Tempe, AZ 85287-1804 http://math.asu.edu/~helene > 回复 全回 转寄 删除 上一封 下一封 返回 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Copyright ? 1999 - 2004 eYou.net. All Rights Reserved