发件人： "Y.C. Chen" 存入地址簿 阻止发信人 加入过滤器 收件人： bkim4@illinois.edu 抄　送： chen@nankai.edu.cn 主　题： Re:A comment on your recent paper on Lebesgue Identity 日　期： Wed, 03 Feb 2010 08:43:04 +0800 新窗口中查看邮件内容 Dear Byungchan, Thanks a lot for your kind words, and for your suggestion. I fully agree with you that the sentence you pointed out should be a standard step to end the description of an involution. We will update it in due time. It was submitted as a note to the Electronic J. Combinatorics. Best regards. Bill >From: Byungchan Kim >Reply-To: >To: "Y.C. Chen" >Subject: Re:A comment on your recent paper on Lebesgue Identity >Date: Tue, 2 Feb 2010 10:48:52 -0600 > Dear Prof. Chen I read your recent paper on Lebesgue Identity from ArXiv. It was really interesting and pleased to read!! I think your map is the simplest among the known one, so it's so elegant. I just have a small comment. How about adding one more line after saying it is clear that the map is reversible. Say, for reverse process, we can determine a partition comes from case 1 or case 2 since \ell(\alpha) \ge \beta_1 . I don't know what to say, but it would be clearer if you say how we can know a partition is constructed by case 1 or 2. Best wishes, Byungchan.